BimmerLife

E39 Front-End Refresh?

Last week, I wrote about a few utterly trivial repairs on the rear of my 2003 E39 530i. I bemoaned some rust forming on the rockers, and said that this may be the harbinger of nearing the end of the line for my decade-long ownership of the car. That may be, but in the meantime, it’s still my beloved daily driver, and I still need to rely on it. And, to do that, I need to keep after it.

There are three issues in the front end of the car that require intervention. The first is a long-standing light thunking. It sounds like rubber as opposed to the far more serious metal-on-metal, but I still need to check it out.

The second is that, about six weeks ago, my son Ethan, who lives with us, told me that he had a brain fart and clipped a curb with the right front wheel. I was not at all pleased, as these wheels and tires were nearly mint when they went on in July. (In fact, Ethan was the one who installed them, as I was at the peak of my back discomfort.) I walked around to the wheel, expecting to see a damaged sidewall and the can-opener treatment to the edge of the rim, but I saw neither. I then drove the car around the block, didn’t feel anything amiss, and felt grateful that the car had dodged the curb-related damage bullet.

But soon after, when I drove it on the highway, something did feel wrong. It wasn’t obviously pulling to one side, but the steering felt wander-y. In addition, hitting the brakes at speed produced a fair amount of steering wheel shudder. Unfortunately, I can’t swear that the shudder wasn’t there before the curb clip.

I jacked up the nose of the car and put it on stands to check all three issues. I first spun both wheels to see if either was visibly bent. Neither appeared so, but the right one didn’t appear to spin quite as freely as the left. So I pulled off the wheels and spun the rotors. Although the shudder was present on the steering wheel and did not produce pulsation of the brake pedal, both rotors did appear to have a small amount of cyclical drag on them. People usually attribute this to “warped rotors,” but it’s more often due to microdeposits on the surfaces. I checked my notes (note that “checking my notes” usually means “googling my own articles” :^) and found that I’d replaced both front rotors in August 2025 for the same issue. I’d bought CarQuest/Raybestos rotors on closeout for $67, shipped. Hell, you get what you pay for, right? Maybe they had gone bad.

But then I remembered more about the rotor-changing episode—that the root cause of the shudder actually wasn’t the rotors but a bad left front wheel bearing. So I pulled off the calipers so the pads wouldn’t drag on the rotors at all and found that, sure enough, the right wheel bearing wasn’t rotating as smoothly as the left. Since I’d replaced only the left one 18 months ago, and since the right one had been involved in a curb clip, it being in need of replacement was certainly conceivable.

I found the other uninstalled FAG wheel bearing sitting on a shelf in the garage, but installing the left one was a pretty serious endeavor, one that I don’t enter lightly due to the combination of the time and effort, my still-fragile back, and the length of time I’ll be without the car.

Installing the left one last summer was a pain.

While the nose of the car was in the air, I gave a cursory inspection to the other steering components, and saw something odd. There’s a small cylindrical collar on each tie rod that the adjustment nut is supposed to tighten against. To my surprise, on the right tie rod, there was a gap between the collar and the nut, and the collar itself wasn’t secured to anything. It’s likely that this was the result of Ethan clipping the curb, but I’m not certain.

That gap shouldn’t be there.

I then checked my notes I mean googled my BimmerLife pieces, and saw that I’d replaced both tie rods pretty recently—new Lemforder components were installed in April 2024.

No gap here.

Looking back even further at the forensics of the front-end work, it appears from the dates on the photos that I did the lower control arms in 2018, and the upper ones in 2021. I know that I’ve never replaced the front struts.

I’m going to make decisions on this carefully. I have no desire to do a full-on front-end rebuild on the car, but I’d hate to do the right wheel bearing and tie rod and not have any of the car’s three front-end problems solved.

—Rob Siegel

____________________________________

Rob’s newly-expanded book The Best Of The Hack Mechanic™: 40 years of hacks, kluges, and assorted automotive mayhem, is available on Amazon here. His other seven books are available here on Amazon, or you can order personally-inscribed copies (including the new Best Of) from Rob’s website, www.robsiegel.com/books.

 

Exit mobile version